By Duane Campbell
Waiting for Superman is an emotional film that follows five public school students who compete in lotteries to attend public charter schools. This film was made by the producer of An Inconvenient Truth, Davis Guggenheim. Waiting for Superman has been screened at a variety of film festivals, including Sundance, and was released on September 24, 2010.
Rethinking Schools editor Stan Karp wrote this after viewing the film:
“The message of the film is that public schools are failing because of bad teachers and their unions. The film’s “solution,” to the minimal extent it suggests one, is to replace them with “great” charter schools and teachers who have less power over their schools and classrooms.
This message is not just wrong. In the current political climate, it’s toxic.”
This film tells a moving story about problems and injustice in public schools but it blames the problems of schools on teachers unions. Why is that ?
Waiting for Superman says several important things about the challenges of the public education system. However, the central message—”charters are good” and “teachers unions are bad”—oversimplifies complicated issues and promotes a particular corporate view of school reform. This is the viewpoint promoted by the Bill Gates Foundation, the Broad Foundation, by Michele Rhee and Joel Klien among others.
Are charters superior to public schools?
First, you need to understand what are charter schools? They are usually public schools using public money but without the direct over sight of school districts, school administrations and school boards. They often do not allow teachers to have a union and they usually do not have a union contract. Charters are established by state laws and promoted by federal legislation including No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top. (more…)
Filed under: Uncategorized | Tagged: AFT, Education, Education reform, Waiting for Superman | 3 Comments »